This Time Right Beat Might
by Wor. Brother
Frederic L. Milliken
The Beehive has often been accused of
muckraking Masonry, exposing the seamier side of Masonry to the detriment of
the Craft. Actually I have written just four major stories that involved
battles with Grand Lodges plus perhaps a few more articles on the state of
Grand Lodges in general.
The big four were the Grand Lodge of West
Virginia versus PGM Frank Haas, the Grand Lodge of Georgia versus Gate City
Lodge No. 2, the Grand Lodge of Arkansas versus Derek Gordon and the Grand
Lodge of New Jersey versus Mike McCabe. In all four instances the Grand
Masters involved took on powers not granted to them by their Constitutions and
pursued paths of Masonic tyranny. We all know that Freemasonry is not a
Democracy but that does not mean that the individual Mason has no Masonic
Along the way the Beehive has turned down over
100 requests from other Brothers who have been dealt a nasty and unwarranted
blow by their Grand Lodge. Their hurt cries out for closure yet a litany of
one injustice after another on the Beehive would soon make it irrelevant.
Fellow Masonic Traveler Greg Stewart just
penned an article titled
Reigns…” where he reports the questionable expulsion of PGM Neal Bidnick
of New York and the firing and suspension of Arizona Deputy Grand Master Mike
Meier. It is the Arizona situation we now turn our attention to.
Stewart writes, “Yesterday afternoon the
Grand Master summoned the elected Deputy Grand Master into his office and in
the presence of R:. W:. Junior Grand Warden William A. Garrard Jr, and
Senior Grand Deacon Mike Manning, informed the Deputy Grand Master he was
suspended from Masonry.”
“The reason the Grand Master gave for
this action, which, in my reading of the AMC, is in conflict with the powers
given to him by the Arizona Grand Lodge, was that the Deputy Grand Master
did not promptly return his apron and jewel of his office, when he relieved
the Deputy Grand Master of his Grand Lodge duties, while he still served as
the elected Deputy Grand Master. The meeting was brief but it was recorded
to avoid any misunderstanding.”
So here we go again. How many times does this
story have to be repeated over and over again from jurisdiction to
jurisdiction before we will take out heads out of the sand and admit we have a
problem? “Houston we have a
The majority view is that these are isolated
incidents and/or that they are none of our business only the business of the
jurisdiction where they occurred. That’s the old syndrome of when Hitler came
after the Jews it was no concern of mine because I’m not a Jew.
Most Masons when they hear of Grand Lodge
abuses and injustices criticize any action but going through the prescribed
Constitutional redress of grievances available in theory in all jurisdictions.
It sounds good but the practical application runs into reality. Theory is
theory and reality is reality and never the twain shall they meet.
Just yesterday The Beehive received a reader’s
comment that took Derek Gordon to task for not following regular channels to
right a wrong on the part of Grand Lodge. If he was charged with something he
must be guilty of something, right?
“Quitting is NOT an American trait much
less that of a Freemason. I’ve read the Arkansas GL By-Laws and there are a
number of remedies for any rank & file Mason to avail himself of, including
legislation at a GL session. I have no idea whether Bro. Gordon committed a
Masonic offense but by AR GL By-Laws he has the remedies of a Masonic Trial
plus the GL in session can disapprove the actions of a GM. (bearing in mind
ANY GL in session is largely rank & file Masons representing subordinate
Lodges. If the various delegates choose to ignore a wrong, shame on them but
unless one follows the procedures, which were agreed to during the Degree
oaths, one cannot complain).”
What would you say in the Frank Haas case where
the Grand Master called Haas and asked him if he was going to be present at
his next Lodge meeting and then worked up some excuse why he asked the
question? When Haas showed up the Grand Master was there waiting for him and
expelled him on the spot, without a trial in front of his father. Do you think
this Grand Master followed his Degree oaths? Why is there never any legal or
moral limitations on Grand Masters?
Maybe the commenter was right as Brother Jack
Buta tells us what went on at the recent Grand Session of Arizona.
“What an exciting day!
Perhaps the best comment on the events of
the first day of the Grand Lodge can be summed up by a distinguished guest
from the Grand Lodge of Maryland. He stated “The Maryland Grand Lodge has
been in business for 225 years during which time I thought that everything
which could happen at a Grand Lodge had happened. After what transpired this
morning, I was proven wrong.”
The Grand Lodge opened to a packed house
with 47 visiting dignitaries from all over the United States, approximately
270 voting members of the Grand Lodge carrying 350 votes. Prior to the
opening, the Grand Master announced to the overcrowded Lodge room that he
was aware several Brothers in the Lodge had plans to disrupt the meeting and
should they try, they would be escorted out of the lodge, their credentials
confiscated and not allowed to re-enter.
The Grand Master opened the Grand Lodge,
the roll call of the Lodges was completed, and the roll call of the Grand
officers begun. At the mention of the appointed Deputy Grand Master, things
began to go from bad to worse. Eleven men stood up in protest, Rick Skoglund,
Jim Moore, and I, on the Grand Master’s right, and eight members of Acacia
Lodge on his left. The Grand Master ignored those of us on the right and
focused in on the 8 members from Acacia. He ordered their removal from the
Lodge room. PM Adrian Fontes, an Attorney in the Phoenix area, who actually
rewrote the Arizona Masonic Constitution in 2011, pointed out that they had
the right to plead their case to the Delegates. After repeated demands by
the Grand Master and receiving the same response, the Grand Master then
threatened to suspend Adrian Fontes, and presumably all the other Brothers
on their feet. Adrian then demanded to know on what grounds. At this point
other Brothers who were not previously standing began to object to the Grand
Master’s actions. Finally, the Grand Master announced that he would close
the Grand Lodge, have the room cleared and if anyone refused to comply he
would call the authorities. At this point more Brothers objected. The Grand
Master slammed the gavel down and ordered the room cleared, and walked out.
However approximately 100 Past Masters, Masters, and Wardens refused to
After a 45 minute stand-off, a compromise
was agreed to. The first order of business would be a vote on whether or not
the Grand Master had the right to suspend Michael Meier, the elected Deputy
Grand Master. This was to take place without further Character assassination
of the Deputy Grand Master.
Unfortunately, the last part of this
agreement was not held up by the Grand Master. After the Jurisprudence
Committee reported the Grand Master did not have the right to suspend the
Deputy Grand Master the General Policies Committee stood up to make a
report. What transpired next was a trial of the Deputy Grand Master.
Unsubstantiated allegations were made, a witness called and a guilty verdict
rendered. Then the Grand Master announced that three Brothers had requested
to speak on behalf of his action. PM Richard McNeil delivered a 4 minute
long list of unsubstantiated allegations of the worst sort on why Michael
Meier should not be a Mason and definitely did not deserve to be Grand
Finally the vote was called for, the
ballots counted, re-counted, and finally announced. The Grand Master’s
suspension of the Deputy Grand Master was set aside in a very tight vote
where the difference was approximately 20 votes.
The afternoon session was rather
anti-climactic. After the Grand Lodge elections the new Grand Master is Jeff
Carlton, Deputy Grand Master is William Garrard, Senior Grand Warden is
Michael Manning. No breakdown of votes other than the total cast was
The point to be made is that Grand Masters are
not God. Neither do they possess the infallibility of the Roman Catholic Pope.
In this case right beat might but is this any way to run a Grand Lodge?